George Smith in True's Cartoon Books: Signed
Two paperback collections from True, The Man's Magazine turned up in the family collection, both published by Fawcett: Cartoon Laffs (Gold Medal #249, edited by Clyde Carley, cartoon editor of True) and Best Cartoons (Crest Book #114, "Selected by the Editors of True").
My grandfather, George Smith, signed at least five cartoons in Cartoon Laffs: the boy behind the iron fence ("Come out and fight like a man!"), the man in the canoe ("You're standing on my mandolin."), the doctor ("I'm worried about you."), and the motorcycle cop's three-panel crash.
When I first looked for his name in that book, it wasn't there. Its "America's Top Cartoonists" page lists 21 artists, including Charles Addams, Virgil Partch, Hank Ketcham and Ted Key. George isn't among them.
But in Best Cartoons, he is: a full page headed "Selected Cartoons of America's Funniest Cartoonists" lists "Geo. Smith," between Stamaty and Chas. Strauss.
What I think happened
The Cartoon Laffs list looks like a marquee list, not a full roster. Other cartoonists in that book, such as Mort Walker and Irwin Caplan, are also missing from it and are known only by their signatures. Neither book ties any cartoon to a particular artist, so the signature in the drawing is still the real credit. Fawcett published both True and Gold Medal, so these were in-house reprints of cartoons already bought. Whether George was paid for the reprints is something I don't know.
George was selling to True in this period. A signed cartoon of his ran there in April 1950, and the archive holds other True material from 1948 to 1952.
One name to keep straight: the Cartoon Laffs list includes a "Claude Smith," and Best Cartoons lists "Claude" separately from "Geo. Smith." A Claude Smith signature I've seen online reads "CLAUDE" in loose capitals, nothing like George's spiky script. They look like two different cartoonists.
If you have a True issue with one of these cartoons, or any Fawcett paperwork from George, please get in touch.










No comments:
Post a Comment